To answer the original question: No. Just no... None of that makes any sense.
I wish we could remove some of these buzz words from our terminology... atonalism... tonalism... shades of gray, man! Like the Tokkemon said: Writing GOOD music that people like is hard. Who cares what style it's in.
If you can make somebody like your music (meaning they were affected in some way that was positive), then you have succeeded in my book. End of story, for me anyway.