Leaderboard

I'm curious to whether this is for double string orchestra, or two quintets, simply because you chose the solo instruments for playback. I would be a little worried about how some sections would carry with dynamic difference between homophonic horns versus polyphonic strings. Part1: Really cool, the way the tremolos in the strings bother had separate and unison dynamic ideas was really cool. The texture of this movement is really cool. The more sparse melodic fragments were quite interesting. I myself am quite partial sustained melodic ideas, but you conveyed this sparser melody very well in this movement. Part 2: A good atmosphere. You are very skilled at connecting very different textures to unifying to a single environment. Atmospheric music is generally not my taste because it doesn't command me to feel an emotion like most, Baroque - Romantic period do. However, I think your music doesn't fail the way most music in this style does. It has emotional bounds that I feel. Part 3: Generally the same ideas as part 1. I really appreciate how even without a strong melody, you are able to very clearly connect the different sections. Also at 17:05, I can't stop hearing Brahms lullaby. I am scarred by that challenge we had earlier in the year.

Hi @Syrel, I am glad that Mr. Peter Pencil has such a spouse Penny Pen who was able to call the Police for him. Either way, Peter the Polish Paper comPoser will politely peruse this piece. LoL Actually - my name on a writing forum I sometimes like to frequent is PaperandPencil which I thought was similar enough to make this silly message. I like this piece and how it constantly starts each section of the piece in a new key just all of a sudden - it's very bold that way. I also think that the piano is a very good lead instrument for this despite it being mostly orchestral - it's very well used as a solo instrument. I really like using piano like this if it's the focus of a piece with a little bit of delay added. Thanks for sharing!

Hi @Awsumerguy! Listening casually without following along with the score it sounds like quite a charming piece! Although I feel like the melody sometimes is a bit unadventurous, lacking in cadential points lending to an impression of being a little lacking in direction (because it seems to wander up and down and clings too closely to the tonic chord for long periods of time and repeating itself over and over in essence creating a piece without any sections but consisting of a long exposition of the main theme over and over and with some key changes). Like I said though - it is a charming idea which I enjoyed listening to. Thanks for sharing!

It's completely understandable to feel a bit disheartened when receiving feedback that challenges your approach to composition or orchestration. However, it's important to remember that constructive criticism is an invaluable tool for growth and development as a musician.