Hello
Among the survey options, I prefer to receive constructive criticism.
The truth is that this space is very peculiar.
On the one hand it is about something specialized such as composition. On the other hand, it accommodates all kinds of levels, from the amateur beginner to the more or less professional.
This is good, although on the other hand it can create imbalances. However, it all coexists very well.
Also the people who comment the most, have very different backgrounds and points of view, which I think is perfect.
What always strikes me is why people, in general, are not encouraged to comment more. Yes, there is the excuse that “I don't have enough knowledge, etc...” It doesn't work for me. Simply commenting I like this or I don't like that is positive.
Besides, to reach something as a composer, even as an amateur, you have to listen and analyze many works, of all kinds.
That is what this forum gives me the most, to know the work of others.