Leaderboard
-
DarwinNE
Members14Points8Posts -
Ali Baghbani
Members12Points9Posts -
Luis Hernández
Members10Points3,420Posts -
Henry Ng Tsz Kiu
Moderators10Points3,180Posts
Popular Content
Showing content with the highest reputation since 11/10/2026 in all areas
-
Trying to write a Fugue
5 pointsHi @draingxngceo! First of all, a hearty welcome here to the forum. I’m very excited about your post, because your passion for fugues and the attempt to compose your own ones after studying the Well-Tempered Clavier remind me of my own first steps in composition many years ago. You have tagged the post with „beginner“ and mentioned that you „don’t really have composition knowledge or experience“. However, the short „sketch“ of an exposition of a fugue is not „nothing“, so I think you indeed have acquired a basic knowledge about fugues through studying the ones from the WTC (or you are just extraordinary talented from nature :-)). That said, some of my more general explanations about fugues below might be obvious to you, but that basic knowledge on fugue writing/analysis might be interesting or useful for other readers, too. Getting started. Before I’ve listened your fugue exposition for the first time, I took a look at the score to get an initial impression. At the first glance, it is not entirely obvious what key the piece is in and how long the fugue subject is. Your fugue subject does not prominently start at the pitch of B or G# and the last note of the fugue subject can only be identified by comparing all three subject entries: It is a B, the first sixteenth note in measure two. Therefore, I am now certain that the fugue is in the key of B major (which is perhaps hinted at by the title “B Majuh,” but—I’m curious—what language is that?). No that is not an error - it makes it somewhat harder to analyze the fugue. With that first impression and the comment of @Luis Hernández I have now taken a closer look at your fugue in order to conduct a more detailed analysis and perhaps offer some suggestions or solutions for the few issues I noticed or that have already been mentioned by other reviewers. Below you will find my annotated score as well as an audio version. The fugue subject. A fugue starts with the introduction of its central melodic material, called the fugue subject. As the fugue subject is introduced by one voice solo, anyone can easily recognize a fugue. A melody to be used as a fugue subject must meet certain requirements in order to be suitable for this purpose: It should have a distinctive melodic and rhythmic character so that it is memorable. The melody may contain smaller fragments (motifs) that can be developed later in the fugue independently. The subject must clearly define the home key (tonic). However, a good fugue subject avoids a final, closed cadence and appears “open” to forward motion. Typically, subjects are relatively short (from one to four bars), although they can be longer, and stay within a moderate range (often an octave or less). The melody should maintain a steady flow - with a mix of rhythmic activity - that creates and preserves momentum. You’ve created an interesting fugue subject that meets almost all of these requirements. I especially like its memorable rhythmic character. Starting with rests (I see, you have studied Bach’s fugues from the WTC where he often starts its fugue subjects with rests), helps that the subsequent subject entries encounter seamlessly in the continuing flow of the fugue and prevents that the fugues rhythm becomes too „static“ or „blocky“. The only „weakness“ concerning the above definitions is that it „meanders“ around the home key B before the tonic is established by the final note. There is nothing wrong with that fact – it might bring some more harmonic freedom or possibilities within the further development. In my annotated score I have emphasized the fugue subject in blue color and marked its start with the letter T (i.e. „Thema“ for subject in German). As you can see, I have separated the last sixteenth note of the subject from the following ones and included a caesura in the phrasing to emphasize the end of the subject and to separate it somewhat from the following sixteenth-notes runs, which represent the (beginning) of the counterpoint. Dux and Comes. Once the subject has been played by the first voice, it is then imitated - one after the other - by the other voices. The answer is not a repetition of the subject on the same pitch, but transposed one, up a fifth (or down a fourth) to the dominant. Such an answer is called “Comes” (i.e., companion), while the original subject entry is called “Dux” (i.e., leader). The third voice enters again in the tonic as Dux, the fourth voice - if present - in the dominant as Comes, and so on (although there may be deviations from the order Dux - Comes - Dux - Comes). Your fugue exposition consists of three voices which create an „ordinary“ arrangement of Dux and Comes: First subject entry as Dux in the Soprano in the tonic key of B major, second subject entry as Comes in the Alto in the dominant ky of F# major and finally third subject entry as Dux in the Tenor (or Bass) in the tonic key of B major. Real and Tonal Answer. Whenever the subject entry by the Comes is a literal, note-by-note transposition of the original subject as played by the Dux up a perfect fifth, we speak of a „real answer”. However, it might be necessary for some kinds of subjects to perform a slightly modified transposition - called „tonal answer” - especially with regard to the dominant note (i.e. the 5th scale degree), if it appears prominently at the beginning of the subject. In the second subject entry you have altered the first pitch from an A# (as it would be when applying a literal transposition) to a B, in order to stay in the tonic key of B major for the first while. That is a kind of a „tonal answer“, but interestingly not applied at the fifth or the fourth, but on the third. There is nothing wrong with it; rather, it proofs that the fugue subject is somewhat „advanced“ or „challenging“ in its harmonic line. Counterpoint and Countersubject. The counterpoint is a distinct melodic line that accompanies the fugue subject (or its answer) in a different voice. It provides musical contrast and rhythmic independence against the main subject. Whenever it appears more than once, it is also called „countersubject” - as it is a recurring companion of the subject, perhaps throughout the entire fugue, but at least during the exposition. It must be constructed to sound harmonically correct when inverted (e.g., if it is used below and above the subject), calling it an „invertable counterpoint”. If the melodic line accompanying the subject does not return regularly, it is considered rather than a formal countersubject. Your counterpoint is a „free counterpoint“, not a recurring one that could be considered to be a „countersubject“. Because of its sixteenth note figures, it moves forward, introducing momentum. Furthermore, especially in bar 5, you have distributed that movement between the Soprano and Alto which is a good example for counterpoint in its rhythmically sense. All in all that rhythmic texture creates a (nearly) perfect „complementary rhythm“, that is when the different voices complement to each other so that there exists a played note on every sixteenth beat, from whatever voice it comes. In the transition from mm. 3 to mm. 4 I have introduced some slightly modifications (highlighted in yellow) in order to emphasize that complementary rhythm, ensuring that all sixteenth notes beats „are played“ mitigating the somewhat „thin sounding“ octave on F# on the first note of mm. 4 (even if it is not a parallel octave, that particular note sounds „thin“ for my ears, causing me to “stumble” a bit while listening). By the way, the tritone in bar 6 – which was mentioned by @LuisHernandez – does not sound so bad to my ears, so my mitigation for that passage is also more a rhythmic modification in the sense of complementary rhythm (with the benefit that the dissonance is shifted more to a passing note): Exposition and Development. The complete, subsequent entries of the fugue subject in all voices is called a development of the subject. The first of that development sections - e.g. the initial introduction of the fugue subject through all voices - is called the exposition, since the subject is presented here for the first time, usually obeying the rules of „Dux and Comes” as explained above, thus presenting the subject in the tonic and the answer in the dominant key. In the subsequent development sections, those „rules” are often interpreted more „relaxed”, meaning that the subject now appears - after a modulation by an interlude (or „episod”) - in other keys (such as related keys as the dominant or subdominant or the parallel key, or even in more distant or unrelated keys). Furthermore, now „fugal arts”, such as inversion, augmentation and diminution and stretto are applied increasingly to depict the subject in an altered nature, or to create tension. In the closing section of a fugue, the subject finally returns to the tonic key, sometimes over a tonic or dominant pedalpoint. There might be a passage after the ultimate subject entry, which is called a coda and whichs purpose is to bring the fugue to the end with the respective cadence. Your short example (measures 1 to 6) is – in my opinion – a good exercise for a fugue exposition. Episodes . An episode is a transitional section that separates the development sections of a fugue, acting as an interlude to modulate between keys and to create contrast. Episodes often feature sequential repetition of a melodic pattern, which contributes to the modulation and creates a sense of forward momentum. As a general “rule”, the complete fugue subject does not appear within an episode. However, episodes typically - though not always - use motifs derived from the subject or countersubject. Measures 7 and 8 could be the beginning of an episode (while I consider mm. 8 „unfinished“ in the soprano part). When listening that final two bars, I could imagine, that the fugue subject re-enters in the second half of bar 8, thus closing the gap in the soprano part with its first upbeat-motif ... Conclusion. I very enjoyed your attempt at composing a fugue and I’m excited to hear more about the success of that fugue(s). Perhaps, my comments and my slightly modified version can be useful in that process. (And as you can see – and hopefully hear -, I have introduced some extend of dynamics, articulation and tempo changes in the score and audio, expressing somewhat how I would interprete the piece as a piano player.) As for the suggestions to start by studying books and trying out “simpler exercises” (such as inventions, etc.) - yes, that’s undoubtedly true. However, if you enjoy trying out writing fugues, I would strongly recommend to continue that - and, of course, study Bach’s fugues from the Well-Tempered Clavier - only the best source is good enough for learning! B-Majuh-piano-steinway-b.mp3 B-Majuh-colored.pdf5 points
-
Sonata per corno, Op. 4 by Maharani (live performance by me)
These days are great in that I can see such nice collaborations like Henry & Vasilis, plus the Peter & Maharani pair! 😊 Peter, these pieces were good to hear. This kind of solo melody music is somehow difficult and you made nice pieces. I love your reverb version and, of course, Maharani's one. I think I like "Sonata" - this is a good opening for starting listening to these. Thank you for sharing. By the way, I've never listened to horn solo pieces. I know solo trumpet, saxophone - jazz sometimes does that but are there any solo horn pieces like that? I don't know. As for solo music, I love Paganini Violin Sonatas, not horn, though. That's awesome, isn't it? Anyway, nice job, both of you! I enjoyed it :) Hello Alexx, you can see Peter's horn in this topic, haha. For your reference! Best, Lithl.4 points
-
Jupiter's Moons
3 pointsHi to all, I recently recorded an electronic music piece at a slow tempo (45 bpm). It is called Jupiter's Moons and I also made a video for it: The main instruments are a Crumar Bit 99 synthesizer, an Arturia Drumbrute Imact, an Arturia Microfreak and the main theme is played on a Stylophone. I hope you'll enjoy it!3 points
-
Moreshka (a folk dance of a fantasy country)
My only comment is on the skill level of the work for musicians. At your tempos you would need an orchestra of highly skilled -if not professional musicians. I initially thought this would be a fun work for the community orchestras I play in; however, I don't know if they have the skill the work requires. It is a FUN work! Mark3 points
-
Minuet in C
3 pointsThank you for sharing this — I listened to the recording and followed the score, and the opening of the A section really charmed me: the light, staccato melody in 3/4 over those steady chordal figures in the lower staff gives it a clear, dance-like lift, and the drop to piano with a crescendo in bars 3–4 is a lovely touch. I also enjoyed the contrast in the B section from bar 16, especially the longer running passage in bars 22–27 under the big slur, which builds nicely before the Vivace A material returns. If I could suggest one thing to explore, it would be varying the left-hand accompaniment pattern a little more in the return of A, so the reprise feels fresh rather than identical — but as it stands, it is a graceful, well-shaped little minuet.3 points
-
Moreshka (a folk dance of a fantasy country)
hello, I’ll be saying a lot about your piece because I’m really enjoy it, and I listened to the entirety of it i’ll probably deep dive on this one because I found a lot of orchestration things that are interesting which I do wanna point out, but let’s talk about the general effect idea Ideas of general effect: as an audience member and also as a person looking at the score, I enjoyed this stylistic idea, listening to it blindly without program notes. This definitely does scream Russian. but after that, I could definitely hear the Jewish/Romanian inflections. I definitely enjoy a fun fast paced folk dance. The harmony was definitely colorful. I must say in the orchestration was interesting as well. Also, there was a great touch with tempo changes as well. You decided to go the abrupt option which makes sense where they seamlessly don’t change rather than a seamless change. Maybe you could’ve experiment with more gradual tempo changes but it’s more of a stylistic choice if you leave them out, which I definitely respect that. Tambourine would go so hard with this. I compose my pieces with a ton of percussion so you could add more percussion if you want, but I get if some composers don’t like doing so. with the general idea with the effect of the sounding its own thing is the effect on that fails as it sounds way too familiar and it feels more of an adaptation on existing earth culture rather than a culture elsewhere. about orchestration I will look at the score, but here is some first impressions I love that thing that you did with the clarinets in thirds that was really creative and it was a quick change of character, which I definitely appreciated. And you definitely passed the idea around as well. I have some questions as well while else re-listening to it, this is more of a stylistic approach on your behalf, but I would definitely add trombone in with that first brass entrance if we’re adding tuba, but then your argument could possibly be that the tuba provides the base and is not as harsh as trombone’s, with page 4, when the melody is passed to the Lows the patterns I would usually see is woodwinds doubling with each other with the additional add-on with strings. The first time with strings you add low brass rather than low Reeds what I was thinking by intuition Page 9 features Viola and clarinets a nice velvety, warm pairing. with page 10 features the thing I was talking about with the clarinet in thirds. A trumpet feature follows after that I would say it’s unusual for a folk color, but it serves well as a pallet cleanser Page 14 contains a call and response sort of idea with the brass note that bass doubles tuba; in the concert band setting this is a strong orchestration technique, given reinforcement in a orchestra given that there’s more string basses the strength and reinforcement is more effective later on the idea was given to the entire orchestra, allowing more color and blending you should be awarded amazing orchestration on this Anyways, this was very fun to look at, and this was full of amazing orchestration3 points
-
Minuet in C
2 points
-
Jupiter's Moons
2 pointsDear @Forty6 I'm really glad you appreciated the piece! Believe it or not, I had never heard the "Space Song" by Beach House, it was completely unknown to me. However, I think I can understand why you see a similarity: the kind of synth patches, the very beginning of the theme and the overall ambiance. In my case, I just had some fun with the Bit 99. Many appreciate it for the Italo Disco vibe, but I tend to prefer atmospheric and airy timbres. I have another space-inspired piece of music written mainly for the Bit 99 that I will post in a few days. It took maybe two or three days of my spare time to put together the chords and the melody, then one week to polish everything. In general I work with successive approximations: the first piece is quite rough, then I try to improve it until I reach a point where I cannot improve it anymore. This does not mean that there is no margin for improvement, of course and I am always glad to receive suggestions and impressions about things that can be done better. There are some deliberate choices though (the limited use of compressors and the catchy theme is not heard until a certain point in the piece).2 points
-
Op 41 SimfoDixi (From the "triptych" album)
"If you've listened to the pieces I've shared here, you've probably noticed that I like working across different styles and aren't afraid to experiment. Some of my experiments might even seem a bit vulgar to certain listeners, but my credo is... don't repeat yourself, try to discover something new, and above all—music should essentially be beautiful (though this last part is just my personal take)."2 points
-
Op 41 SimfoDixi (From the "triptych" album)
I completely see the fusion haha It's all so bouncy, it carries a momentum that holds you in your seat for its entirety and I love the trombone that comes in at 0:33, I don't even know how to describe the feeling I get when I listen to this, while at first that it seems like it's a very dancy, bouncy kind of carnival song, then it sounds like it's more witty in a way (again, I have no idea how to describe it...) Anyways, great job!2 points
-
Bach - Capriccio BWV 992 (partial orchestration)
2 points
-
The Door Opens
2 pointsHi all, I finished my new work that had no title ... It took a while to find a suitable name. But here it is. The Doors Opens As it states .... please walk through. Mark As always open to improvements or inquires. The Door Opens 11-13-26.mp3 The Door Opens 11-13-26.pdf2 points
-
The Door Opens
2 pointsI am so very very pleased you enjoyed "The Door Opens". It took me an entire afternoon to settle on a title! I am fortunate to play in a few orchestras these last 39 years ... it provides me an intimate aural setting. This I believe helps my orchestrations .... 🙂 Can't help but hear it all from Bach to Prokofiev to Copland. It's very different playing amidst all the wonderful sonorities than just listening. Mark2 points
-
Looking for peer reviews for this piano and bass clarinet piece: Sad Song, April 2026
Thank you for your kind reply, Laurent, and best wishes to you in France as well. I am glad the balance between the piano and the bass clarinet came across, especially that opening where the piano's repeated pattern keeps moving while the clarinet enters with its low, warm line. Do you have another piece for this combination in mind, or are you planning to explore a different pairing next?2 points
-
Minuet in C
2 pointsYou are very welcome, Martynas — I am glad the comments were useful. Your minuet stayed with me because that light staccato opening in 3/4 and the warm B-section contrast from bar 16 give it such a clear, dance-like character. Are you planning to write another dance movement to pair with it, or to develop the B-section material further in a longer piece?2 points
-
Looking for peer reviews for this piano and bass clarinet piece: Sad Song, April 2026
Thank you for your comment and your suggestion. I'm glad you enjoyed the piece! I suppose it's meant to be a slightly different take on sadness than usual: a contrast between the simple melancholy resignation of the clarinet and the agitation of the piano. I hope that comes across a bit nonetheless... Thanks again for taking the time to listen. Best wishes2 points
-
Suite for mezzo-soprano and string quartet, “Forlorn Images”.
Part III. I liked the opening, with the strings creating an almost ‘cosmic’ atmosphere (as in Lohengrin). The first exposition with vocals/text left me wanting a bit more, as the strings play a very passive accompanying role, with nothing more than long notes. But I noticed that in the recapitulation they take on a much more active role, so the contrast works well. Overall, I like the way you give the instruments such a prominent role, even though it’s a composition with text and vocals.2 points
-
Moreshka (a folk dance of a fantasy country)
Hello! Thank you so much for such a detailed review and for your positive feedback. As for whether the music comes across as something of its own or as an adaptation of the music of our world, perhaps I didn’t phrase my idea very well in the opening post. I actually wanted the music to resemble the music we know. By “its own” I meant not something invented, but something heard since childhood and well settled in memory. I wanted it to feel familiar, but not to be merely what one’s memory supplies. The novel itself, which this piece was written to illustrate, is a fantasy work set in a world strongly resembling Europe before and during the First World War. Naturally, there are references to the Russian Empire as well. For example, the author even added poems that directly recreate the style of the so-called Silver Age of Russian poetry. And I wanted to do the same thing in the music. However, I’m only describing my intention :) It’s by no means certain that I succeeded. A composer often can’t tell the difference between what he planned to create and what he actually ended up with :) Special thanks for the praise of the orchestration :) It’s very pleasant to hear. Thank you :)2 points
-
Ancaibe
2 pointsNice to meet you! First, I want to say this melody you made is familiar, catchy, memorable, and I think it's nice. Playing the main melody on bass or guitar might be nice. I like it. Anyway, it doesn't matter, just my impression when I listened to this. Ok - about mixing. I think you're doing well using panning and making all instruments clearly recognizable. I always have my attitude to respect what you want to express even if the mixing sounds unusual. For example, if the bass note was so strongly panned or much stronger than other instruments, if you have some purpose it would be part of creativity, I think. So please keep this in mind, as I'll give you what is called "general" mixing tips. I'm not sure what kind of sound you want to achieve, but starting around 1:25 many elements come in although the right-panned bass sound has almost not changed, and it's not clear in that section, which is what you call muddy or something like that. Solution: be careful about reverb and volume, use 3D panning plugins like Parallax Audio, or—it's a bit different, but—you'll be able to use PanCake. I think the biggest improvement right now for your situation is "volume". You can adjust volume balance - changing balance and finding your preferred version; if it's found, that means you have better mixing and can improve like "oh, I like this one better - this one sounds better" to the point you are satisfied. And leaving the work for one day and readjusting the mixing is so powerful. Also, writing down your vision or ideas about placing, mixing, and trying it anyway. I suppose the most important thing is not to compromise. Pursuing what you want to do with "no compromise"! Observing your favorite mixing/music is important too. Your piece has several nice parts and ideas, and I don't know the details about your game project, but this piece has a hopeful, beautiful vibe, so keep it up. Happy to hear your piece and welcome to YC, Forty6! Side note: just in case you're not familiar with it - Plugin Boutique is powerful for finding new free VSTs. However, be careful—there are a bunch of free VSTs in this world, so you need to choose great ones. If there are too many, you'll probably have no idea what to use, so at first, watching YouTube reviews like "best free reverb" and discovering nice ones is a good idea. Best, Lithl.2 points
-
Suite for mezzo-soprano and string quartet, “Forlorn Images”.
Hello I’ve listened to the first two tracks; I’ll listen to more tomorrow… It’s a shame that, particularly with vocal works, we have to use our imagination quite a lot, given the virtual instruments we have. I think it’s a fantastic piece, with a distinctive harmonic language that I haven’t bothered to analyse – nor do I need to, because it sounds phenomenal. The choice of a string orchestra alone feels rather ‘restrained’ (one could imagine a larger orchestra), but I think it’s a good choice.2 points
-
The Door Opens
2 pointsA beautiful score and piece of music. I think it keeps you engaged throughout. Brilliant orchestration. There are moments that I might perhaps have approached differently, but it’s simply a matter of one style versus another. Orchestrating is about making decisions all the time, and it’s brilliant. Thank you for sharing.2 points
-
Jupiter's Moons
2 pointsMany thanks, @PeterthePapercomPoser Two years ago, I (almost) discovered I had Final Cut pro that was coming along with Logic Pro when I bought it with my computer. So I thought it was the occasion trying to put together some music video. They require a lot of work, though, but I had great fun doing it. For my electronic music, I don't usually notate everything, but I still like to work on paper to scribble notes and thoughts. I found nice to show them in the video 😅2 points
-
Jupiter's Moons
2 pointsWelcome to the forum @DarwinNE ! I left you a thumbs up, subscribed and also a comment on YouTube! I'm impressed by how differentiated the video is! Including your own music notation of the composition as well as yourself playing it and also natural landscapes was just great to see and hear! I would have loved to see some images of Jupiter's moons thrown in as well! Thanks for sharing and welcome once again!2 points
-
Varenna Suite
2 pointsHi @Lithl and many thanks for your very nice comment! I like that melody, too, I'm glad it was appreciated. I did not know Parallax Audio's Virtual Sound Stage, thank you very much for the hint! Varenna Suite is a piece that dates back from 2023, in the meanwhile, I improved my setup using much better headphones (Audio Technica ATH-M50x). At least from what I can judge, I am getting slightly more balanced results in the final mix 😊 I have to say I quite like BBC Symphony Orchestra Discover. It lacks certain things and this is normal being a free instrument. I would appreciate more extrovert brasses in the forte/fortissimo range, for instance. I am going to post some of my electronic music with pleasure. I acquired a vintage synth a few months ago and I am still rather enthusiast about it 😎2 points
-
I love you, for SSAATTBB Choir
2 pointswonderful feedback! I appreciate the fact you've listened to it multiple times. Thank you for the corrections, I'm going to fix the stems on 51 (and the same thing in the altos in the beginning). I have accepted the parallel octaves, wait until you find all the 5ths in the innervoices. I do agree that the tenor 2s are a little low at times, but I'm not sure if I could do much to fix that at this point. I wrote this with a specific 40 person choir in mind https://open.spotify.com/track/63UKqUzlYZmKgsIu8UEw0F?si=7c7f696d83dd4501. I understand the range of sopranos is a little crazy, but I don't intend all the sopranos to sing every note. Especially on their low notes, I kept the sopranos in on measure 14, I felt as though the sopranos should know that the [e] on pickup to 15 is not an entrance, but the continuation of the phrase. I don't even care if the sopranos sing the low notes, but I do care that they not "come in". I'm not sure how else I could make this clarification without it becoming an unnecessary burden to the eyes. For the low bass low notes, that is my voice part so I felt comfortable with what I wrote. I do sort of wonder if m. 6 will work out how it sounds right now, since it is not a very harmonically anchored chord. I can see how the 3 way split could be overkill, I think that last chord could be a little more balanced, especially with the tenors and sopranos being tutti while the basses and altos are divsi.2 points
-
Varenna Suite
2 pointsHello and nice to meet you, Mr. DarwinNE! I'm glad you are here. I wanted to comment on this piece of yours, but I have had something to do so far. My first impression is that the melody starting around 1:25 is so beautiful. Catchy, heartfelt music and I felt what you want to express, your musical vibe. Some mixing points caught my attention - about clarity: I think you've already gotten familiar with it, you know, like Parallax Audio's Virtual Sound Stage — you might be able to adjust it in more detail. However, overall, it sounds great so, no problem. I'm looking forward to you dropping what you wrote recently. Also, looking at your profile and notes, you make electronic stuff, right? Please post it too - in this forum, electronic stuff is usually quiet, haha. Thank you for coming here - let's enjoy YC together :) Best, Lithl.2 points
-
I love you, for SSAATTBB Choir
2 pointsI listened a few times to this piece and I like it. I for instance really appreciate the planing harmonies constructed by the voices. I love the structure of the piece with the charming central section. If you are planning to have it sung by a real choir, I have a few doubts about the choice of vocal ranges. You are asking your sopranos to reach a low A in bar 14 and to reach a high B in bars 45-46, that is an extension over two octaves. While there are certainly sopranos comfortable with a high B natural, they may not be very happy (or expressive) while singing in the very low register two octaves lower, even if doubled by the altos. The tenors, even when divided, often sing in a medium register, more fit to baritones (especially T2). Especially in the more expressive parts of the piece, you may ask T1 to sing higher for a longer moment and reach a high G# that remains comfortable and sure and keep the T2 in the register that you are currently using for T1. Beware of the deep registers for the basses that may sound cavernous and give results that are not what I think you would expect. If you are not lucky, a low E may not sound tender and elegantly controlled, as required by the piece. Concerning the writing style, for instance in bar 51 the following bars, how is the divisi expected to work with T1/T2? If the quarter notes have to be sung by both tenors, I would put a second stem oriented downwards. I spotted a few parallel octaves between the parts, such as in bar 13 between the S/A (that are singing together given the very low register of the S) and the B1. If it is intentional I am not shocked by it 😊 I wonder if the triple divisi in the basses is really required for the last note.2 points
-
Microtonal Prelude in A subminor
2 pointsHello again. I have composed yet another microtonal piece - this time a prelude for lumatone (or a piano). My intent for the piece was to explore subminor and supermajor chords, as well as the subminor 7th which is a more pleasing sonority in a minor or dominant 7th chord which isn't as dissonant and yearning for resolution (the dominant 7th chord with a subminor 7th is a common sonority that gives Barbershop quartets their characteristic sound). I think a performance on a lumatone can probably best approximate my intentions with this piece in 31 edo or 53 edo or something. Thanks for listening and I'd appreciate any comments, suggestions, critiques or observations you may have!2 points
-
string quartet No. 1 *Needs review*
2 points
-
string quartet No. 1 *Needs review*
2 pointsWith the third movement, and I think the fourth movement there is some issues with the viola’s going out of range. Their lowest note is a C you have stuff going down to a B you could probably get that with the cellos.2 points
-
Trying to write a Fugue
2 points@Wieland Handke Thank you for the very in depth response! I actually did not know about this complimentary rhythm thing but I think it was something I was doing instinctively. For some reason I was actually avoiding it somewhat. I think I was trying to give the music room to breathe or something. And I think I might have focused too much on each line being independent and having a very coherent melody when played just by itself. At first your modifications sounded awkward to me of course I am used to my own version but after a few listens they do make a lot of sense.2 points
-
Nocturne in e minor (miniature)
2 pointsI really like how the piece patiently unfolds it's texture and content without trying force it's melody out so strikingly against the accompaniment, rather they compliment one another to create that moodiness, the erraticness sounds natural rather than abrupt... The continous motions of the accompaniment make the pauses in the ending measure and the ending feel well-earned rather than just reached.2 points
-
Moreshka (a folk dance of a fantasy country)
Yes, you’re right, this music is intended for a professional orchestra. I was aiming at the level of an average symphony orchestra that plays the standard repertoire of classical concerts: symphonies, overtures, tone poems... Of course, wherever possible, I tried to avoid unjustified difficulties. But the very character of this music pushes toward complexity. The tempo, the syncopated rhythms, the asymmetrical meters (like 7/8) create the image, but they also give the musicians a hard time. Thank you for the positive feedback. I’m very glad that people enjoy my musical illustrations :)1 point
-
Bach - Capriccio BWV 992 (partial orchestration)
Welcome all. Here is my attempt to orchestrate a lament from Bach's BWV992 keyboard suite. The original is mostly one and two part material: so I had to invent several new counterpoint lines; otherwise the orchestration sounded too thin. I'm currently working on the other movements. Wonder if you think my added counterpoint is successful? The suite was suggested by an AI, when I asked which work by Bach was crying out to be orchestrated, where no prior orchestral arrangements exist. I know there are lots of note-stalks pointing in the wrong direction, as well as missing a2 directions, and missing slurs; but can you see any other problems? Bach - Capriccio (BWV 992) #8 (partial).mp3 Bach - Capriccio (BWV 992) #8 (partial).pdf1 point
-
Melodic Rhapsody
1 pointHello Tristan, thank you for sharing the reworked version — I listened and followed the score, and I enjoyed hearing how the piece has moved away from its waltz origins into something freer. The opening works well: in 3/4 at Moderato, the right hand's singing line sits clearly over the left hand's chordal accompaniment, and the little triplet turn in bar 4 gives the melody a gentle lift before the rising arpeggiated figures in bars 6–8 open it out into a longer, flowing phrase. That contrast between the song-like opening and the more rhapsodic, free-flowing middle is what gives the piece its character. One suggestion, echoing Mark's comment: the opening theme is so memorable that I wanted to hear it return or develop more later on, so you could try bringing a varied form of it back near the end, perhaps in a different register or with a fuller left-hand texture, to tie the rhapsody together. Did the reworking change the ending as well, or did the free-form middle grow out of the original waltz ending?1 point
-
Nocturne in e minor (miniature)
1 pointHello islav, thank you for sharing this — I listened and followed the score, and I was struck by how patiently the piece unfolds. The opening is especially effective: the right hand waits through the first bar, then answers with that high descending figure and fermata in bars 2–3, while the left hand keeps the nine-note groups moving underneath in 9/8. That contrast between the still, singing line and the continuous accompaniment gives the harmony room to shift without the melody ever having to hurry, and holding E minor back until the very end makes the arrival feel earned. One suggestion: because those wide leaps in both hands can blur which line is the melody, you could try thinning the accompaniment slightly or softening the lower nine-note groups where the right-hand line is at its highest, so the singing line stays in front. For a subtitle, something like “Nocturne — After Rain” or “Nocturne — Late Light” might suit that quiet, harmonically driven mood. Do you hear the piece as a single nocturne, or as the start of a set of short night pieces?1 point
-
Suite for mezzo-soprano and string quartet, “Forlorn Images”.
Thank you for such an interesting review. As for the “cosmic” sound, you are largely right. This movement contains images of the otherworldly, or rather, hints of them. Vika Osadchenko, the poet whose poems this suite is based on, wrote the lines that formed the basis of this movement shortly after the death of her mother. Below, I asked Claude (an AI) to translate the poem into English so that you can understand what it is about. if only I could remember how to pass through these doors if only I could remember where the little boat to the other shore is what to say and where to put the coin was it thrown into the river, for remembrance or something It spins, it spins, the little planet. See, there is as much darkness as light? It’s not frightening at all to fall. the milky eternal path is dimly familiar it spins it spins somewhere morning will come the body autumn leaves, see-through blown away somewhere by a gentle cold wind See, there is as much hope as not-knowing. Whatever may happen to us in this life, see, we are always on the border of light?1 point
-
Looking for peer reviews for this piano and bass clarinet piece: Sad Song, April 2026
Thank you Ali for your message and your appreciation of the piece. Best wishes from France. Laurent1 point
-
Minuet in C
1 point
-
Looking for peer reviews for this piano and bass clarinet piece: Sad Song, April 2026
Hi Luis, Thank you very much for your words, I'm so glad you enjoyed the piece. I know what you mean about how it doesn't quite go in the direction suggested by the opening bars. It is a bit of an odd feeling, I agree, which sometimes I get and at others I don't so much, but I haven't yet quite managed to work out how it comes about. But the way the piano works towards these moments of agitation is central to the theme. About the clarinet, it sounds like a bass clarinet to me, with its somewhat hollow woody timbre, even on the high notes, which conveys a specific kind of sadness in contrast to the often agitated piano. But then again I was not there when it was recorded, so I can't be entirely sure... Thanks again for your comments. Best wishes1 point
-
Jupiter's Moons
1 pointI love this so much! The way the melody develops, starting from the chords to then the satisfying dunnn-dunnnnnnn (G flat to F flat) THEN WHEN IT OPENS UP (liek around the exact halfway point) it just sparks everything that I think of when I think "Jupiter's Moons" (especially that Stenophone paired with the twinkling) and THEN to close it with chords and that satisfying melody is just so poetic and perfect. I have to ask, do you know of the song "Space Song" by Beach House? It's really popular online, did you take inspiration from that song? It sounds even more within the aesthetic than Space Song did (if you ask me.) How long did this take to make (the composition itself, not the editing process) Consider me wowed, Forty61 point
-
Looking for peer reviews for this piano and bass clarinet piece: Sad Song, April 2026
Thank you for offering, For melody, I like the satisfying resolution on ending with the root note for the clarinet, (I know this wasn't the feedback you asked for, but) When I listen to the song, I don't initially think that the song would be considered sad, I more felt like it was intriguing and somehwat bouncy, if you wanted to make it sound a bit sadder, I feel liek you could make the piano softer and have a bit more reverb (just in general less sharp) and a slightly lower bpm maybe? I do like the song a lot, though, it's always so nice hearing live instruments (atleast I think it was live) like how you played the clarinet yourself, and I liked the switch ups of instruments like with the other piano coming in later to change around the atmosphere, great job! Awesome sauce, Forty61 point
-
Favorite Album Ever
1 pointI forgot to mention this album: Outlaw Star OST (my favorite anime) My favorite tracks are: FLIGHT POWER GENTLE SUZUKA GRAND EXPECTATION DAY BREAK1 point
-
Suite for mezzo-soprano and string quartet, “Forlorn Images”.
Thank you for the positive feedback :) I’m very glad you liked the suite. The ensemble could indeed have been larger; at the very least, a string orchestra could have been used. But I deliberately chose a quartet because I wanted a chamber feel. I perceive this work as very intimate. Besides, it’s much easier to find five performers (a vocalist plus a string quartet) than a whole orchestra :) I hope the remaining movements won’t disappoint you :)1 point
-
Arpeggio Etude for Piano
1 point
-
Would It Be Beneficial to First Learn a Piano Piece in Silence or at Low Volume, Before Moving on to Full-Sound Practice and Refinement?
Wow, I can't do that at least as of now, unless very slowly, likely very much away from the intended tempo, or that it is a really really slow piece1 point
-
Piston
1 pointNot sure where you're based. In the US, courts require "meaningful human authorship" to claim copyright, not just human contribution. You did not author the final product, just the prompt. It is possible to claim copyright to your part, but not to the final recording. Suno may have granted you commercial license rights if you paid them extra, but that is not the same as being able to claim copyright. Also, after listening to music created with Suno like this, I'm always less and less worried about AI music taking over. The use of kitsch and corny elements are through the roof, seem to have no relationship to the genre/style of the original concept, and have a redundant, non-developing form. "In my AI ethics course, any user that creates with AI is the sole author." - I am quite curious as to what sort of unreliable AI ethics course would be promoting this, as it's standard knowledge that all writing, graphic, and musical LLMs are only possible because you are not the sole author.1 point
-
Piston
1 pointThose are very different things. If I buy a hydraulic press and use it to flatten a stainless steel pipe, obviously I'm morally responsible for flattening the pipe. If that pipe belonged to someone else, I can hardly evade responsibility by saying, "Hey, it wasn't me! It was the hydraulic press!" On the other hand, it's equally obvious that I can't lay claim to flattening the pipe as a feat of strength. If I cry, "Behold my strength!" as I hold the flattened piece of steel aloft, I am quite rightly met with, "Uh... you didn't do that. The hydraulic press did."1 point
-
Arpeggio Etude for Piano
1 pointThis is really beautiful! I would love to hear a "finessed" version of this piece, as the MIDI isn't doing it justice at all. I like the choice of time signature change in the middle, I think that was a really clever way of developing the piece.1 point
-
Pearl's Casting - "Should I teach in a public school?"
Using cards and dice to guide instrumentation is really creative. Choosing the violin as the main solo instrument and the vibraphone for accompaniment based on the suits drawn adds an interesting dimension to the piece.1 point