Fermata
Old Members-
Posts
41 -
Joined
-
Days Won
1
Fermata last won the day on October 18
Fermata had the most liked content!
About Fermata
Profile Information
-
Gender
NA
Recent Profile Visitors
Fermata's Achievements
-
counterpoint Feedback on my first Fugue
Fermata replied to bhelloworld420's topic in Advice and Techniques
I've marked most problematic parts (see the attachment)- 4 replies
-
- 1
-
- composition
- feedback
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
counterpoint Feedback on my first Fugue
Fermata replied to bhelloworld420's topic in Advice and Techniques
There are several contrapuntal issues that need to be corrected (I can annotate them in your score if you wish, but mind you, there are many). Personally, I don't think it's a good idea to jump straight into fugues after a few exercises in 1st-species counterpoint as the gap between the two is huge. You should at least get into florid counterpoint, invertible counterpoint and imitations in minimum two parts before attempting fugal writing at all. As for the structure of your fugue... The disposition is basically good (just make sure you don't exceed the range of any voices). I suggest consulting examples no. 891 and 892 from Albrechtsberger's book (I guess you're somewhat familiar with his textbook) - you may want to analyse them (mark the subjects, answers, possible countersubjects, the keys the theme modulates to, stretti etc.).- 4 replies
-
- composition
- feedback
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
3 voice 1st species counterpoint Feedback
Fermata replied to bhelloworld420's topic in Advice and Techniques
The last one is quite good! The cantus firmus with the alteration (marked with *) is actually better than the original.- 1 reply
-
- 1
-
- counterpoint
- harmony
-
(and 2 more)
Tagged with:
-
1st Species Counterpoint Feedback
Fermata replied to bhelloworld420's topic in Advice and Techniques
Using octaves (or unisons) in 2-part counterpoint give very incomplete harmonies that's why they're not used except for the 1st and last measures. A battuta occurs when you approach an octave in contrary motion from an interval larger than an octave - it has been considered unelegant compared to approaching octaves from the "inside". -
1st Species Counterpoint Feedback
Fermata replied to bhelloworld420's topic in Advice and Techniques
I've checked the first page and the last four exercises, see the attachment below. There aren't really any serious technical problems, though. If something is not entirely clear, feel free to ask. -
Six Voice Fugue from String Sextet in G-flat major, 2nd Movement
Fermata replied to Henry Ng Tsz Kiu's topic in Chamber Music
Very impressive! I can't really add anything new to the superlative comments others have posted above... A very emotional and expressive work which was quite an enjoyment to listen to! May I ask what your technique was to achieve six-part counterpoint with such an intricate theme? I mean, I've done myself several counterpoint exercises for more than four voices, but always with simple stile antico themes... How did you go about working out this complicated subject? -
Revision of an old exercise of mine composed on a given subject while experimenting in counterpoint in more than four parts.
-
Thanks for the comments! That final cadence has a strong plagal flavour (my original version had a much more straightforward g min - D maj progression there), I'm personally unable to hear it as not giving satisfactory closure. Back at university my fugal training was based predominantly on the French system (see for example Gedalge's treatise) according to which episodes are considered as developmental parts unlike the Baroque practice where they're just transitional parts, hence my different approach. I understand your point, though, I'll try to keep an eye on this next time when making another fugue from scratch. Thanks!
-
A four-part fugue for composed upon a given subject (it was originally written in SATB open score). The slurs are only meant to indicate phrases. Had fun with designing the episodes but I'm still not quite satisfied with them.
-
Important facts regarding the Fugue
Fermata replied to Luis Hernández's topic in Advice and Techniques
Here's a very basic crash-course I made which discusses the structure of fugal answers from a slightly different point of view. -
Important facts regarding the Fugue (II): stretti
Fermata replied to Luis Hernández's topic in Advice and Techniques
If it's of any help, I've just made a tutorial on how to design subjects for tonal fugues that allow canonic stretti. -
Important facts regarding the Fugue (II): stretti
Fermata replied to Luis Hernández's topic in Advice and Techniques
There are actually two kinds of stretti: a) the real or canonic stretto where the subject goes on in full while the answer is sounding; b) and the false stretto where the subject is continued in free counterpoint right after the entry of the answer. You can compose a false stretto with any subject you create. As for a canonic stretto you first have to create a subject which is suitable to be worked out as an actual canon with very close entrances. -
Done! Thanks for the suggestions!
-
Thank you for the reply! It's quite amusing (in a positive sense) that you found the entries of the subject few in number as I deliberately tried to avoid re-introducing them at every modulation - I guess it's due to my training which didn't rely heavily on Bachian procedures . As for adding the inversion it might be quite a good idea - I've just tried it how it sounds and it does seem to work rather well, both strict and free! As this was originally an exercise sketched out in SATB open score with no particular instruments in mind I didn't consider these issues big at that time but I think you're right - I'll bear your comments in mind when trying to make real music.
-
Revision of one of my old contrapuntal exercises for a small ensemble. The subject was given. The slurs in the score are only meant to indicate phrases. Still needs some tweaking.