-
Andaluza
I want to share this little piece. It was originally a bit longer, written for solo piano. But I used it for an orchestration exercise and shortened it. It’s based on Spanish dances and themes. At some points, I wasn’t sure if certain things were possible on specific instruments, but my professor—whom I trust completely—gave it the green light. I hope you like it because of its folk-inspired sound. Best regards. ANDALUZA.mp3 Andaluza.pdf
-
My first piece for an ensemble, Sinfonietta for Wind Instruments
Hello I’ve listened to Part 1 on YouTube, because I like to look at the score. Your ideas are very good, but I think there are a few things to consider in terms of orchestration. I’m no expert, but that’s my opinion. The opening catches the ear because I don’t think those pp dynamics up there on the flute are feasible. The clarinets are playing figures that are typical of the piano – not very idiomatic – but, what’s more, with no rest for so many bars, they need to catch their breath. Another thing I’ve noticed is those very long notes that form the harmony; they don’t sound right on these instruments. The harmonic foundation needs to move; in fact, in an orchestra, everything has to be alive.
-
Bach - Capriccio BWV 992 (partial orchestration)
Hello I love the way it sounds. I can’t remember the original – I’d have to listen to it again to compare – but I don’t need to, as it works really well for me just as it is. I don’t know which parts have been added, but as it all sounds very cohesive, I don’t mind. I think that when you orchestrate something, you can be very, very literal or the complete opposite; the important thing is to do it with flair or with a purpose. The chromatic descents sound phenomenal. The oboe with the muted trumpet is a combination that might seem a bit odd at first, but when the trumpet is muted, they blend together beautifully. When the full string section comes in on bar 34 – although it’s not exactly the same, even in terms of instrumental density – it reminded me of Wagner, or Maher. Perhaps because of the chromaticism present. What a crazy but intriguing idea – Bach-Wagner. I’m sure Wagner studied Bach.
-
A Waltz for Ning
Hello A very moving piece. I think it ties in very well with the Romantic tradition – what remains of it, at least. I love watching people play. But as my interest lies in composition, I like to look at the scores – if there are any – as I always learn something from them. I liked the linear descent at 1:24.
-
Suite for mezzo-soprano and string quartet, “Forlorn Images”.
Part III. I liked the opening, with the strings creating an almost ‘cosmic’ atmosphere (as in Lohengrin). The first exposition with vocals/text left me wanting a bit more, as the strings play a very passive accompanying role, with nothing more than long notes. But I noticed that in the recapitulation they take on a much more active role, so the contrast works well. Overall, I like the way you give the instruments such a prominent role, even though it’s a composition with text and vocals.
-
Suite for mezzo-soprano and string quartet, “Forlorn Images”.
Hello I’ve listened to the first two tracks; I’ll listen to more tomorrow… It’s a shame that, particularly with vocal works, we have to use our imagination quite a lot, given the virtual instruments we have. I think it’s a fantastic piece, with a distinctive harmonic language that I haven’t bothered to analyse – nor do I need to, because it sounds phenomenal. The choice of a string orchestra alone feels rather ‘restrained’ (one could imagine a larger orchestra), but I think it’s a good choice.
-
Looking for peer reviews for this piano and bass clarinet piece: Sad Song, April 2026
Hello First of all, I’d like to say that I found the piece lovely and very pleasant to listen to. At the start, the piano has quite a ‘minimalist’ pattern, but then it breaks away from that and sounds a bit odd. However, given the prominent role the piano takes on later, I think it’s fine. I haven’t checked the range or anything. But could the clarinet be a standard one rather than a bass clarinet? In many places, it’s in quite a high register. Thanks for sharing.
-
The Door Opens
A beautiful score and piece of music. I think it keeps you engaged throughout. Brilliant orchestration. There are moments that I might perhaps have approached differently, but it’s simply a matter of one style versus another. Orchestrating is about making decisions all the time, and it’s brilliant. Thank you for sharing.
- What if a Big Band and a Full Orchestra could play the same arrangements? Two free arrangements for you!
-
The Golden Lakes | For Concert Band
Hello A fantastic piece, rich in colour and beautifully orchestrated. I find this sort of work for wind bands to be a rather distinctive genre, and by no means an easy one. In the area where I live (Spain, on the Mediterranean coast) there’s a very strong tradition of street bands (marching bands?). They play whilst marching the whole time and consist of dozens of clarinets, oboes, flutes, sometimes saxophones, and percussion—including timpani, which are constantly pushed along by two assistants. There are many bands here and they play at the local festivals. For example, in many villages and neighbourhoods, ‘Moors and Christians’ festivals are held (lasting 3–5 days), as this country was under Muslim rule for seven centuries (from 711 to 1492) and these festivals re-enact the final Christian victory. Anyway, it’s fascinating. And that’s why we have such a wonderful Muslim heritage in this country in every aspect (traditions, cuisine, the language). These bands parade with various groups throughout the day and play pasodobles, music that sounds ‘Arabic’, and so on… That’s why I’m so fond of this sort of band. Anyway, sorry for rambling, but I’d like to congratulate you on this music.
-
Piano sketch or not for orchestrating and composing
@AngelCityOutlaw Thank you very much for your contributions. Of course, I understand all the different viewpoints and situations. The thing is, even though I’m still at an intermediate level (I think) when it comes to orchestral composition, I almost always write directly for the orchestra. First comes the idea – which might be a melody, but is often something else – and I already picture which instruments will be used, and so on. But my current mentor on these matters remarked that in orchestration, if you have good voice leading, you’ve got a large part of it sorted. And in this regard, he recommends using a sketch – not a standard piano stave, nor a piano reduction. Rather, use two, three or four staves (depending on the size of the orchestra you’re using) to outline the ideas and structures. Of course, I think he’s right. But I find this method useful when you’re developing an orchestral work of a certain scale, length, structure, and so on… For something lasting just 3 minutes, I don’t see it as necessary. I also think, as you mention, that it’s not the same whether you have all the time in the world to compose and orchestrate, or whether you have to work whilst adapting to deadlines and other people. And of course, reading the biographies of the greats – Verdi and Wagner, for example – it’s clear they did make sketches on the piano… But they didn’t have the digital tools we have today, and it was their only way not only of structuring tremendously complex works, but also of creating their ‘demos’ to present and rehearse their works. Best regards.
-
The Best Textbook and the Best Teacher
Throughout my experience as a student and as a self-taught musician in various areas of music, one thing has become very clear to me. There are two types of educators, of teachers: those who theorize endlessly (and have never composed anything) and those who are actual composers. I don’t mean to say that just because someone is a composer, they’ll automatically be a good teacher. This year, I’ve been fortunate enough to have a teacher of orchestration. He’s also a composer by profession. And he doesn’t follow or directly recommend any book, treatise, or anything of the sort.... He says—and he’s right—that the real learning comes from the scores themselves. The most valuable thing I’m learning is how to find solutions to the things I want to orchestrate, rather than formulas for instrument combinations, etc. And I want to give an example that has caught my attention recently. I was listening to Otello by G. Verdi. And I noticed that, no matter what’s happening in the score—which is a lot and quite complex—there’s a pedal in the low register of the organ with three notes in a cluster: C, C-sharp, and D. This pedal lasts six and a half minutes!! And you can hear it in the background, especially with headphones and, I imagine, in a live performance. Why did Verdi write this? Why doesn’t it clash horribly with the rest of the music? These are the questions I’ve learned to answer. What do you think of this musical device?
-
“The Last Request” (a decadent romance)
A lovely song. A very passionate composition that suits this style of romantic song perfectly.
-
The Crystal Maiden (piano miniature)
A curious and lovely piece. You’ve made good use of the piano’s range. At first, the very high register can be a bit tiring, but this is soon offset. It would probably sound good on a celesta, an instrument we associate with this sort of scene.
-
Trying to write a Fugue
HELLO Let me just say that if you have no experience in composition, you’ve got a long way to go before you can compose a proper fugue. I get the impression you must have some knowledge of counterpoint. But before you start composing fugues, you need to master other, less demanding areas of strict counterpoint. It’s simply not possible to come up with a logically structured composition just by studying two of Bach’s fugues and leaving it at that. What you’ve written doesn’t sound bad, but, in my opinion, there’s a point (which I think is the one mentioned by @Lithl ) where everything falls apart quite a bit, and that’s in bar 6. Because you’re forming a D#–A tritone which, although the intention is for some of these to be passing notes, I think that should resolve into a Bb chord. Enharmonically, you have Eb–A, a tritone which, in this context, must resolve in this way. The solution you’ve suggested for another context is fine, but here, at least for me, it ruins the whole thing.