Barcarolle

Thank you everyone for your messages and advices. I will start a new invention and try to do it better. 🙂

Thank you for all these precious information ! For me this accidental sounds nicely, why do you say it is "out of context". When should I use it or not ? I wont copy Bach but I think it will be the best reference for learning :).

Thank you very much for your complete message, it will help me. I will begin another invention with a better structure. If I understand correctly, for an invention it could be good to use a A, B, A (A = main key, B = dominant key) ? And between A and B section I have to find a modulation chain ? I will also study Bach a lot. Technically is my counterpoint correct ? I learn by myself so I have no teacher to correct me.

Thank you ! Writing a correct structure is pretty hard for me. I would really like if someone could give me some keys to understand it better (Tips, videos, books...)

Hello, I started to compose a new short piano piece with 2 different voices. I have not finished, I still have a few measures to write. Can I ask your opinion about this work ? Do you have any advice for me to progress ?

Thank you ! I will still work to do more elaborated counterpoints (with more voices). 🙂

Thank you

Thank you for your message. I am glad you liked it. You are right, it is not necessary to do too complex things. I started to learn counterpoint and I decided to start a more elabored work... something like a sonata. I just started to write the introduction (a few seconds). It is a good start in your opinion ? Can I improve it ? I also share a little melody idea using my small counterpoint knowledge.

Thank you very much ! Your message encourage me to continue. I am thinking about writing some minuets inspired by classical composers to progress.

Wow, it sounds totally awesome for me. I loved it !

Hello, I play piano since 10 years with a teacher and I try to learn composition by myself. I read some books about harmony, it is a bit hard for me. I think I will try to learn counterpoint soon. This is a very short and simple piece I composed to practice : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KEWll4yVbRg I am very impressed by the quality of the works in this forum. I am posting here because I am searching for some advices to progress and learn how to compose more elaborated pieces. Please excuse my mistakes of english, I am french. Thank you