Bruno

This is quite a short composition that I wrote quite recently. Any comments would be really helpful! Piano 2010

I think this ended too suddenly.

Ok, thank you

Very Good and very dramatic

I enjoyed it. It reminded me of someone running through a dark, misty forest.

I couldn't agree more. :thumbsup:

I enjoy music from a lot of different periods including modern I can enjoy discordant music, but only when it's cleverly resolved or hidden within a cord. Overall, I think that heavily discordant music isn

I've listened to some of his music, at points it was really nice to listen to but It would have been far better without discords. The music seemed to move on without having resolved the previous phrases which I found frustrating. At times the discords where resolved, these where the better parts. I think that perhaps as I hear more discordant music I will begin to like it more. I think that discordant music is much harder to listen to and I think it's a shame that so much of modern music is (in my opinion) spoiled by discords. Prehaps modern, discordant music is one of the reasons why "classical" music is not as popular as it used to be. People must be put off the genre because when they first listen to it they can't appreciate it properly because of all the discords.

There's nothing wrong with liking discordant music. I'm just interested in what it is that people like about it and how discords can be used without sounding like mistakes or just bad music.

I've listened to K.552, these discords where resolved, I said that Mozart would never use discords without resolving them.

Ok I'll get reading

Mozart didn't use dischords without resolving them or having a good reason for using them. Good music can often include dischords. They can be fantastic for creating tention, but what I don't understand is music which is full of dischords from begining to end, if dischords are sopposed to be unplesant then why are they used in this way. Could anyone explain this?

I'm talking about minor and major 2nds and 7ths. What I don't understand is how a piece of music consisting of discords be good to listen too.

Since I joined this forum. I've noticed that a lot of the more modern compositions by people using this forum seem to use clashing notes. But Why? I just don't seem to be able to appreciate it. I'd really like to understand what it is that makes people want to compose in this way. If I understood the reasons for composing in this way then I would like to try composing in this style. If you sometimes compose with discords and clashing notes could you explain why?

Hi, It's great to have some feedback. I feel encoraged by your comments and I'm really pleased to have some ways that i could improve this. I'm going to do some more elaborate variations. I have also attached the finale file so that you can see the score. Piano Sonata.mus Thanks for the feed back :)