Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

I like it in that sense too. But, there are different ways to do vibrato, and I'm sure there is some way it can work in other situations, IMHO...

Posted

Ok, for one vibrato is not a cover up of an instrument's "pure tone". Straight tone is boring on any instrument. Vibrato gives what the player is performing color and a uniqueness to their playing. If everyone in the world played with no vibrato then it would be almost impossible to tell the difference between them. Although it is usually not orthodox to play anything before 1850 with vibrato, I feel that music is about change and revolution. Classical music is no different. If everyone played everything the same til the end of time, no one would want to listen to classical music. Thats pretty much the only reason why this genre isnt a dead art is because musicians changed the way music in the classical and early romantic periods was played so it could inspire new ways of writing.

Vibrato sur le saxophone est

Posted
Thats pretty much the only reason why this genre isn't a dead art is because musicians changed the way music in the classical and early romantic periods was played so it could inspire new ways of writing.
That is hardly (if at all) much of an inspiration... Mozart liked vibrato on clarinet, so bringing it back isn't really changing much.

I think vibrato stands out too much on clarinet. The timbre on the clarinet makes it way to prominent.

Posted

Vibrato was originally an ornament, not a tonal ideal. There's a quote from Leopold Mozart out there somewhere chiding violinists that "tremble upon every note as if suffering from a palsy" that I find particularly apt.

Personally, I feel that most musicians can occasionally use vibrato to good effect, but many simply overuse it, which is often frankly tiresome.

Of course, if you want to omit it, you can specify "no vibrato" in your works when appropriate...

Posted
My former horn teacher plays the Alphorn with vibrato. That's some really weird combination :cool:

Allright the first question, does anyone have a clip or video that actually shows horn vibrato, or what it sounds like?

2nd question, in a piece of music would it be appropriate just to put "no vibrato" as to signify that I want no vibrato, or is there a special term for it?

Posted

Okay, this fellow uses multiphonics on horn, and I heard a speckle of vibrato, but just a speckle.

Autumn Leaves

The following is a massive Horn Festival in Columbia, and the beginning of this video starts with the Siegfried Long Call, and you can hear some vibrato notes here and there, but just a little. The opening solo to Titanic Fantasy after the Siegfried call also is played with some vibrato here and there, but you have to listen closely.

Siegried Long Call, Titanic Fantasy

Festival de Cornos

Posted

I think that both clips sound good with thta kind of vibrato. I fact, that is exactly what I like! Hopefully I'm not the ONLY one...

Also... the guys in both clips are constantly out of tune... :angry:

Posted

Yes, and to tell the truth, horn is one of the instruments that you really have no excuse for playing with bad intonation on, the right hand is there to fine tune everything, so intonation can be as perfect as on a trombone or stringed instrument.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...