How good are you at timing...

No, it's the same thing with ALL the random pointless threads on this forum.

"Is Atonality dead?"

WHY ARE YOU ASKING THAT QUESTION?

"Is tonality a force of nature"

SERIOUSLY, NOBODY NEEDS YOU TO ASK THAT QUESTION

"Who's the BEST COMPOZAR EVAR?!?11?"

OPINIONS ARE OPINIONS, NO NEED TO SPARK DEBATES ABOUT THEM.

etc. etc.

you get my drift?

Maelstrom, if anywhere my thread coexists, please point it out for me. Save me some trouble.

cool the "rhetoric" in this thread or it will be shut down.

Am I seriously the one and only person who understood exactly what Schumann was getting at. I find so many responses to threads in this forum completely outrageous. But instead all I am learning is that I am just weird.

You probably are weird like me. That doesn't mean you aren't qualified.

Schumann, seriously, with all you respect, I think you must try to explain in better words the meaning of your original post in order to receive useful answers, otherwise, most of us keep feeling unable to create the proper discussion this site was designed to. Because now I feel we're wasting your time as well as our time. Is not lack of enthusiasm, interest or willing to help, just you give us a help so we may help you.