Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

Hi everyone, I'm currently in the planning stages for my next piece and I was thinking I'd like to incorporate a children's choir into it, the trouble is I don't know the vocal ranges. I'm assuming that there is no bass, but other than that I'm not sure what register is possible. Anyway, I hope you can help.

Thanks! :)

Jackson

Posted

different countries childs have different ranges, even if that sounds weird ...

in general terms,

I'd say that....

Soprano Boys Bb3 to G5

Alto Boys G3 to Eb5

Soprano Girls C4 to A5

Alto Girls A3 to F5

that's what I've noted, I might be wrong

Girls in overtones ..... up to G#28 ..... :D

Posted

Children's choirs usually range from "dear god make the noise stop" to "shut the brats up, please!"

Children's voices are not meant to be heard.

Posted

That involves reaching for the nearest bookshelf. Clicking and typing is much easier than getting out of a chair to find a book. And if said book does not reside on aforementioned bookshelf, it now becomes necessary to A) find out what book has the necessary information B) buy it. All of this probably involves (god forbid) leaving the home, thus you can see why people prefer to just ask other people on internet forums.

Btw., what ranges have you found to be erroneous on Wikipedia.org? There's probably a reason for why they have what they have. If you take issue with it, change it. It's Wikipedia. If somebody changes it back and asks for a source, there's a Talk Page for a reason.

Posted
Children's choirs usually range from "dear god make the noise stop" to "shut the brats up, please!"

Children's voices are not meant to be heard.

you are NO FUN!!!! (but... I kinda agree with you)

The only time I liked childrens voices was in Orff's Carmina Burana.

Posted
The only time I liked childrens voices was in Orff's Carmina Burana.

Yes but do you realize how Orff uses the ragazzi ... that's why I asked "where do you (Jacksonlast) plan to "incorporate" the childrens choir ?"

Posted
Yes but do you realize how Orff uses the ragazzi ... that's why I asked "where do you (Jacksonlast) plan to "incorporate" the childrens choir ?"

Oh... good point. haha.

Posted

"keep it on the treble clef staff" is generally a good rule of thumb. Or maybe a bit below. But why do that? Kids can't sing. Only time it's good to have children in a choir is an all-boys treble section in a Palestrina mass.

Posted

Okay, it sounds like the Children's Choir is a bad idea... I only wanted to use voices in the upper register and have a piano filling out the bass clef, so that's why I was thinking a children's choir. I suppose I could just write it for soprano and alto adults though if Children's Choirs sound as horrible as everyone seems to say.

Jackson

Posted
That involves reaching for the nearest bookshelf. Clicking and typing is much easier than getting out of a chair to find a book. And if said book does not reside on aforementioned bookshelf, it now becomes necessary to A) find out what book has the necessary information B) buy it. All of this probably involves (god forbid) leaving the home, thus you can see why people prefer to just ask other people on internet forums.

Btw., what ranges have you found to be erroneous on Wikipedia.org? There's probably a reason for why they have what they have. If you take issue with it, change it. It's Wikipedia. If somebody changes it back and asks for a source, there's a Talk Page for a reason.

I don't remember, quite a few. Also its interesting that you seem to suggest that having an orchestration book is a bad thing.

Posted
Okay, it sounds like the Children's Choir is a bad idea... I only wanted to use voices in the upper register and have a piano filling out the bass clef, so that's why I was thinking a children's choir. I suppose I could just write it for soprano and alto adults though if Children's Choirs sound as horrible as everyone seems to say.

Jackson

Yeah, go with SSA chorus. That ensemble is so neglected anyhow, it'd be good to get more literature.

Posted

you mmmmmay use the childrens, just don't leave them alone, :)

literally and musically.

Children voices may add some different color to the total voices, but the children alone, not, I don't think so, .... and please .... don't use a children as a solist. bad bad bad

The other day I bought a version of Bach Matthew Passion, but I didn't realize in the solists names were a male name in "Soprano" .... when I listened to it and when "Ebarme dich" came on ...... wuorrrrr horrible, horrible, I almost wanted to go to the store and tell them "here's your disc (3 cds actually) I want my money back"

Posted

That's true... Children's voices under some SSA or even High Males can add a timbre that is a unique sound. Bernstein did it in his Mass, I believe, (even though he had them alone at most points).

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Unfortunately, your content contains terms that we do not allow. Please edit your content to remove the highlighted words below.
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...