chopin Posted September 25, 2009 Posted September 25, 2009 Edit: Please see this I need help with a few things. I need a list of music styles and music eras. This list has to be as comprehensive as possible, and we can always add to it later. An example of a music form: sonata, etude, waltz, ballade, tone poem, scherzo, free form, etc... An example of an era, or genre: Renaissance, Baroque, Classical, Romantic, Contemporary, etc... I need to cover most possibilities. Thanks! Quote
SYS65 Posted September 25, 2009 Posted September 25, 2009 you mean like a Dictionary or terms ? ... :hmmm: like this ? Prelude Postlude Interlude Prelude and Fuge Fuge Toccata Toccata and Fuge Etude Piece Piece Lyric Suite Suite Lyric Sonata Sonatina Ballade Symphony Symphonic Poem Symphonic Fantasy Tone Poem Overture Improptu do I continue ? Quote
Voce Posted September 25, 2009 Posted September 25, 2009 There are a lot of lesser-known "styles" in good ol wikipedia. Category:Western classical music styles - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia Quote
robinjessome Posted September 25, 2009 Posted September 25, 2009 Okay....let's do this in a more structured manner, so we can catch them all. Anyone remember the "Top-100 whatchamacallits" threads we went through a while back? Just like that. Take the list, copy it, add to it, post it. Next person does the same. Keep it in alphabetical order or I will ban you. Here's a starting point, off the top of my head: GENRES: 20th-Century Adult Contemporary Ambient Baroque Bebop Dixieland / Trad-jazz Delta Blues Classical Country & Western Dance / Techno / House Disco Drum n' Bass Electronica Emo Folk Free-Improvisation Free-Jazz Funk Hard Bop Heavy Metal Klezmer Minimalist Opera Pop Pop-rock Post-bop / modern jazz Prog-Rock Punk Reggae Ragtime Rap R & B Rock Rock n' Roll Romantic Salsa / Latin Smooth Jazz Swing .... Now, GO! Quote
chopin Posted September 25, 2009 Author Posted September 25, 2009 Yes yes, this is what I need. @ SYS65, that sounds about right for forms (although they have to be playable styles, not dictionary terms). I don't expect to catch everything, but I am hoping to catch most Genres. Then I need to capture most Styles. This little "game" that Robin created may sound silly, but this is actually very important. Anything missed, can be added later in the future. Quote
Guest Bitterduck Posted September 25, 2009 Posted September 25, 2009 GENRES: 20th-Century Adult Contemporary Ambient Anti-Folk Baroque Bebop Blues Dixieland / Trad-jazz Delta Blues Death Metal Classical Country & Western Dance / Techno / House Disco Drum n' Bass Electronica Emo Folk Free-Improvisation Free-Jazz Funk Hard Bop Heavy Metal Klezmer lo-fi Math Rock Metalcore Minimalist Opera Pop Pop-rock Post-bop / modern jazz Prog-Rock Punk Reggae Ragtime Rap R & B Rock Rock n' Roll Romantic Salsa / Latin Screamo Smooth Jazz Swing Quote
robinjessome Posted September 25, 2009 Posted September 25, 2009 Side note @ Chopin. Just how specific do you want this? Do you want: "Latin" ...or... "Rhumba" "Guanuanco" "Salsa" "Cha-Cha" "Samba" .... Do you want: "Electronic Dance" ...or... "House" "techno" "Rocktronica" "Trip-hop" "Dub-step" "Breakbeat" ... ?? Just curious...because, we can fragment these styles all day long, but a lot of them won't matter. :hmmm: Quote
Salemosophy Posted September 25, 2009 Posted September 25, 2009 I made my additions bold... GENRES: 20th-Century (this is technically an 'Era' of musical styles/genres, not a Genre) Adult Contemporary Aleatory Alternative Rock Ambient Anti-Folk Baroque Bebop Blues Dixieland / Trad-jazz Delta Blues Death Metal Classical Country & Western Dance / Techno / House Disco Drum n' Bass Electronica Emo Ethnic/Ethnicism Expressionism Folk Free-Improvisation Free-Jazz Free-Tone/Free-Atonal Funk Futurism Hard Bop Heavy Metal Impressionism Industrial/Industrial Techno Klezmer lo-fi Math Rock Metalcore Minimalism Modernism Neo-Classicism Opera Pop Pop-rock Post-bop / modern jazz Post-Minimalism Post-Modernism Post-Romanticism Prog-Rock Punk Reggae Ragtime Rap R & B Rock Rock n' Roll Romantic Salsa / Latin Screamo Smooth Jazz Spectral Swing Techno Trance Quote
SYS65 Posted September 25, 2009 Posted September 25, 2009 OK, so I Continue Serenade Song Rhapsody Concerto Concertino Symphony Concertante Concerto Grosso (well a bit old ....) Symphonietta Fantasy Intermezzo Variations Theme and Variations Choral Hymne Dance(s) March Funebre March Symphonic Movement Capriccio Opera Operetta Aria Duo, Trio, Cuarteto, (etc) Arabesca Messe Religious terms like, Miserere, Ave Verum, Te Deum ...uuuuuu many more) Terms like Adagio, Andante, Allegro (sometimes used as "Adagio for Strings" ) I come back when I recall more.... Quote
chopin Posted September 27, 2009 Author Posted September 27, 2009 Does anyone know how to categorize music properly once we reach the more modern genres? As of now, we are categorizing music by: Genre Style or Form Instrumentation (based on our upload forums) Is a piece a movement? Key Signature, if any. Numbers 1 and 2 can become tricky once we get into the mid to late 20th century, and even more confusing in the 21st century. For example, can the Genre Pop have a Style or Form associated with it? If so, what? If not, are there any suggestions on how I would categorize music of the mid to late 20th century, such as Pop, Pop Rock, Rock, Metal, Jazz, Blues, etc? Also, if there are more suggestions on how to categorize music uploads please let me know your ideas. Quote
Ferkungamabooboo Posted September 27, 2009 Posted September 27, 2009 You might do better to have the instrumentation and broad genre be the main groupings, and then have something like pandora for suggested music... That way people interested in a given style will be able to grow and learn something from the site, instead of grouping it by self-identified characteristics. allmusic's genres are pretty good. Wikipedia's also got a humongous list that'll have similar biases to this list. Quote
chopin Posted September 28, 2009 Author Posted September 28, 2009 I'm not sure how to approach this, there seems to be too many genres and sub genres (for example, ragtime is a sub-genre of Jazz, but I may call Jazz and Ragtime top level genres for simplicity). The way I currently have this set up, is that a user can input a genre by typing it into a text field. I wanted to have set values, so that there is no chance the autogen directory would be messy. I think certain forms, such as "sonata, or etude" only apply to Western Classical Music. Since 95% of our current user base composes this type of music, I feel a text box for "form" should also be a category. This is the list that I need, I feel Wikipedia's list is too vague. I can use Wikipedia's list for genres, it seems comprehensive enough. Quote
Morivou Posted September 28, 2009 Posted September 28, 2009 You might try allowing MORE than one genre... So that they can apply more than one. Like tags... people search for Ragtime, they will find the Ragtime... they search for Ragtime and Jazz, they get the ones that fit BOTH descriptions. Quote
chopin Posted September 28, 2009 Author Posted September 28, 2009 I will have it that if someone chooses ragtime, they will automatically be found for Jazz, so that will be taken care of. I have an idea of what I will do. It looks like I have to create a chart with Genres and Subgenres. Then for the "Classical" genre, that will get its own category for form. The Wikipedia entries confuse me though. They list these as top level genres: Classical Music (Art Music) - this will contain all the music 95% of us compose on this site, at least, to this date. Traditional Music (I will probably omit this category) Popular Music Blues Country Electronic Folk Heavy Metal Hip Hop Jazz Reggae Rock What I am confused about, is that Blues, Country, Electronic, Folk, Heavy Metal, Hip Hop, Jazz, Reggae, Rock are put under Popular Music as well. But they are listed as a top level according to Wikipedia. How could they be both a top level and subgenre of Pop at the same time? For example, I am not sure if I should have 2 top level Genres: Classical Popular Music And the Subgenres for Pop would be Blues, Country, Electronic, Folk, Heavy Metal, Hip Hop, Jazz, Reggae, Rock. The Subgenres for Classical would be Classical, Romantic, Impressionist Music, Minimalist Music, etc. Or should I have Blues, Country, Electronic, Folk, Heavy Metal, Hip Hop, Jazz, Reggae, Rock as top level genres, along with Pop, and Classical? Quote
chopin Posted September 28, 2009 Author Posted September 28, 2009 Also, since YC will be categorizing works more effectively, does our current upload forum structure make sense? For example, I am thinking we should break the forums by instrumentation. I am going to have many of you observe the structure of the network before we go live, because I want this to make sense. For example, our upload forums are inconsistent. Orchestral & Large ensemble, chamber, choral/vocal, piano/keyboard all indicate instrumentation, but Incidental/Music & Soundtracks, Jazz, Band, Pop/Rock do not indicate instrumentation, they indicate genres instead. So this is a case of inconsistency we have had all this time! :facepalm: And remember, with the new generation of YC, we want to accommodate for all types of music, not just classical. Quote
Ferkungamabooboo Posted September 28, 2009 Posted September 28, 2009 I feel Jazz&Blues is its own category, which would include Ragtime, Reggae, etc. But that's me. And I think that's the biggest issue with what you're talking about -- how i group the genres won't be how everyone does. Maybe a tag-based system would work better? But then, you'd need a tag relation system so that Jazz and Funk end up in the right subgrouping.... As to "pop" covering rock, etc... you'd have to set arbitrary distinctions... Quote
chopin Posted September 28, 2009 Author Posted September 28, 2009 Can anyone here help me with my genre chart? I referenced wikipedia for the information, but I would like to have a few eyes look over the chart. I broke up genres by using two top level categories, Art Music, and Popular Music. Art music contains the European Classical Music movements. Popular Music contains most commercial music, such as Blues, Rock, Pop, etc. Each Genre has a subgenre, and even a sub-sub genre. I need this chart to be as accurate as possible. It has to cover most music that our current user-base composes in, but it also has to cover other popular genres for our future user-base. I will share the doc file in Google docs, so for those of you who want to help me, please click here and start editing the genre chart! I made editing public, so I would need a list of people who are helping me work on this chart, and please make any edits in RED. Quote
Lord Skye Posted September 28, 2009 Posted September 28, 2009 I have a huge moral problem calling "art music" by that term. Can we just keep it at "classical" or "modern classical" if you will? I mean, it's already in parentheses. Quote
Ferkungamabooboo Posted September 28, 2009 Posted September 28, 2009 Looks fine to me, honestly you won't cover them all, and I think you should have a write-in section that adds to the list, even once it's up and running. (basically a "if you can't find it, we'll make a spot for you") A few thoughts: the group of 6 was more of a "school" than a genre; no one will write in that style again. NJ Shore sound -- lol. I have a huge moral problem calling "art music" by that term. Can we just keep it at "classical" or "modern classical" if you will? I mean, it's already in parentheses. Not to derail, but care to explain? I find "art" music much more broad and covers nonwhite musics. Quote
chopin Posted September 28, 2009 Author Posted September 28, 2009 I'm wondering if we should expand on the "Classical Music (Art Music)" category. After all, this is the group that will get the most attention during during the first year of the network, I am sure. Quote
James H. Posted September 28, 2009 Posted September 28, 2009 MAIN genres: Classical Music (Western composer stuff) Search by one of three criteria:Era/Style Contemporary 20th century Romantic Classical Baroque Renaissance [*]Form Symphony Sonata Tone Poem Minuet Sarabande Scherzo [*]Instrumentation Orchestra Wind band Choral String quartet Wind quintet Instrumental solo Keyboard Woodwind Brass String [*]Popular Music (stuff like guitars, annoying singing and all that =D) Rockmetal [*]Pop [*]Electronic techno [*]Folk country bluegrass [*]Hip Hop/Rap [*]Jazz (blues, ragtime, "jazz") [*]World (eastern music, ethnic styles (klezmar, romanian folk music, celtic, ect)) [*]Incidental Music (Marius-stuff) Is that any better? :veryunsure: Quote
robinjessome Posted September 28, 2009 Posted September 28, 2009 ^^^^^ James nails it. THAT makes perfect sense. I think any reference to "form" (i.e. structure - Sonata form etc...) or "key" are irrelevant and useless as factors for categorizing the music. James's'ss FIVE categories make it quick and easy to refine your focus... Quote
James H. Posted September 28, 2009 Posted September 28, 2009 I refined my list up there. Understanding that any piece of music can smear between several of the finer delineations, make it possible for a user to select several. For example, if a piece could be categorised under "romantic style" and "20th century" at the same time. Most of my own music does this. It's not one thing, but sort of a mild mixture of a few indicators. Also, make it an OPTION to select these finer categories, rather than making it mandatory for each piece submitted. Quote
chopin Posted September 28, 2009 Author Posted September 28, 2009 I also need your help on our forum structure. I suggest you go onto our test site, sign up, and upload music. You will see a drop down. The drop down choices correspond to where the music will be posted in the forums. The forum names should be categorized by popular instrumentation. This would serve as your instrumentation category: For example: Orchestra Wind band Choral String quartet Wind quintet Instrumental solo Keyboard Woodwind Brass String Each of the above should be a forum category. If you play around with the test site, you will start to understand what I mean. Quote
chopin Posted September 28, 2009 Author Posted September 28, 2009 And you know what, I probably will have this "chart" as an aid somewhere on this site, so people can understand how to categorize their music. Proper categorization is going to play an important role on YC. Categorizing music will be optional, however "strongly" encouraged. It will improve visibility, so that people who are looking for your particular style, can find you! I think any reference to "form" (i.e. structure - Sonata form etc...) or "key" are irrelevant and useless as factors for categorizing the music. I don't think so, it helps those who are looking for particular "moods" or "forms" find the music they wish to find. The goal of YC is to help aid people with similar interests in finding YOUR music easier. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.