The J Posted August 16, 2010 Posted August 16, 2010 i've found this awesome site : http://imslp.org which consists all composers and their scores, but some of them are still protected by copyright, heh, go figure :) like the rite of spring of stravinsky. i'm using it for studying purposes only, so its not really stealing. anyone knows more sites? Quote
bkho Posted August 16, 2010 Posted August 16, 2010 Thanks for the link. http://www.musopen.com is another site with free scores. i've found this awesome site : http://imslp.org which consists all composers and their scores, but some of them are still protected by copyright, heh, go figure :) like the rite of spring of stravinsky. i'm using it for studying purposes only, so its not really stealing. anyone knows more sites? Quote
charliep123 Posted August 16, 2010 Posted August 16, 2010 i'm using it for studying purposes only, so its not really stealing. Yes it is. Quote
Peter_W. Posted August 16, 2010 Posted August 16, 2010 (Kind of moot, IMSLP doesn't have Rite of Spring) It's not stealing depending on how much you are copying and what you are doing with it. There are Fair Use provisions, you know. However, you'll have a hard time arguing that photocopying ALL of it is strictly for educational use. And usually "educational use" means teaching, not just studying. If you want all of it, you really should just buy the score. Think of it this way: if you're using Fair Provision as an excuse for some other end (like owning the entire score at no charge to you), it's probably illegal. People still do it, but just realize that it's an illegal photocopy. Peace. -Pete Quote
charliep123 Posted August 17, 2010 Posted August 17, 2010 However, you'll have a hard time arguing that photocopying ALL of it is strictly for educational use. Well, you can argue it all you want, either way its illegal. There is a limit to how many pages can be photocopied for educational use (i.e. copying the entire thing is illegal no matter what). Quote
Peter_W. Posted August 17, 2010 Posted August 17, 2010 There is a limit to how many pages can be photocopied for educational use (i.e. copying the entire thing is illegal no matter what). Right. Quote
jawoodruff Posted August 17, 2010 Posted August 17, 2010 From my understanding, most -if not all- of the scores on imslp are in the public domain. They take great care to ensure that the copyrights on the scores themselves have lapsed. If a work is on the site that has an active copyright it will not let you download it (I've seen this myself.) Besides, how is taking a score of a piece by Palestrina (who's been dead now about 400 or so years) stealing? He no longer is alive... there's no heirs alive of his anymore, so is it really theft? Quote
Peter_W. Posted August 17, 2010 Posted August 17, 2010 We were talking about composers whose works are still under copyright. Stravinsky's works are still under copyright, he only died about 40 years ago. Palestrina's works are PD (Public Domain) and thus can be legally downloaded, copied, arranged, etc. The laws are a bit different once you look at EDITIONS or specific arrangements of PD works. The edition or arrangement could be under copyright. You're right, IMSLP is pretty good about only allowing PD works to be uploaded to the site. Quote
bryla Posted August 17, 2010 Posted August 17, 2010 It would benefit people to read up on their copyright knowledge before claiming it's stealing ;) IMSLP is and will always be only PD stuff - period. Depending on the country the composers come from, the typical span from time of death to termination of copyright is from 70-80 years. HOWEVER!!!!! Russia has VERY different regulations on these matters, and one really has to know the individual cases to know. I doubt that IMSLP wouldn't know. Quote
charliep123 Posted August 18, 2010 Posted August 18, 2010 It would benefit people to read up on their copyright knowledge before claiming it's stealing ;) Take your own advice. IMSLP does look at country-specific copyright laws. If you take Webern, for example, it clearly states that, while his works are protected in the EU and US, they're public domain in Canada and other countries. Thus, they're up with the assumption that only people in those countries willl download them. This isn't always the case, as I, in the US, could download them. This is illegal. Quote
bryla Posted August 18, 2010 Posted August 18, 2010 I do follow my advice.... and where do you prove me wrong? You're actually proving me right. Quote
Max Castillo Posted August 18, 2010 Posted August 18, 2010 There's also a Russian one: http://notes.tarakanov.net/ Use a translator. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.