Michael Armstrong Posted April 12, 2013 Posted April 12, 2013 Why do we avoid the augmented second between 6 and 7 in harmonic minor in voice leading? I always get called on this in my compositions, but I use that interval on purpose. It sounds so expressive and pulls so strongly to tonic, why avoid it? It's not like singers can't sing it now. Contemporary singers should find an augmented second very easy to sing. It isn't hard on any instrument. So why? Why do we avoid the augmented second in voice leading? Quote
Sojar Voglar Posted April 12, 2013 Posted April 12, 2013 Only in very strict harmonic progression of classical harmony there is a tendency to create a bridge between a hole that augmented 2nd delivers when using harmonic scale, because any augmented interval was considered a dissonance. It does sound more natural if you compose in style of Mozart or similar to use rising and falling scale (when going up, augment the 6th degree, and make a natural drop when going down), since that interval sounds curious and a bit oriental when used as a scale material throughout very classical progression. Did you upload anything that delivers such seconds in general? Which one is that? Quote
Michael Armstrong Posted April 12, 2013 Author Posted April 12, 2013 http://www.youngcomposers.com/music/4104/fugue-in-a-minor/ My fugue in A minor has several. Quote
jessesmac Posted May 5, 2013 Posted May 5, 2013 I didn't know the A2 between the 6th and 7th in harmonic minor was a mistake. I quite like it, actually. Quote
U238 Posted May 5, 2013 Posted May 5, 2013 Why do you need someone else to validate your desire to use this sound? Quote
keman Posted June 17, 2013 Posted June 17, 2013 I didn't know the A2 between the 6th and 7th in harmonic minor was a mistake. I quite like it, actually. Strictly speaking it is considered a mistake when it's not part of the melody voice. Since a fugue is mainly based on double counterpoint, you shouldn't use them at all. I'm not sure there is a good explanation for this, it's just part of the way people perceived music during the baroque period. But the point is: If that interval is not an essential part of your compositional idea (if it's not part of the melody voice), there's really no good reason to use it either, it will just sound very exposed and probably make your music sound worse than without it. 1 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.