Review Trading

I spent a considerable amount of time on my current piece and haven't had enough ears on it. Nobody has said anything on here, and so I would be willing to offer a critique of any two pieces for the return of the favor if anyone is interested.

You're surprised no one listens to your music, eh? Why? You're a blatant jerk most of the time. 

You're surprised no one listens to your music, eh? Why? You're a blatant jerk most of the time. 

Who said I was surprised?

I'm offering a service, to be paid in trade.

That's nice, but it's not really the behavioral trend of the website. So, nahhh.

 

I'm offering a service, to be paid in trade.

Who wants to hear "your piece sucks, just give up now", which is probably what those reviews would be like.

I'd personally try the being nice method.

Also there's no score

Some people just want to watch this site burn...
Learn some manners, kid.

I'm almost half tempted to believe you're a troll. However, this crude behavior seems to really be characteristic of all your interactions on this forum. Let me count the things I see wrong with all of this:

• You are averse to the idea of being nice to others (for unclear reasons, I might add).
• You expect adequate feedback without the willingness to offer the tools by which that feedback would be better and more easily provided (the score, that is).
• You take every opportunity to be rude to people and seem to enjoy finding excuses to be insultingly vulgar.

Despite this little list of grievances against the site, you have done nothing to me. So I will give you this wisdom to ponder:

Has it occurred to you that we already do trade review with each other? You could have been doing it already. We do it every day by reviewing other people pieces, responding to their questions, and welcoming newcomers politely to the forum. We show everyone a certain level of decency and the favor is returned when others do the same for us. If you had started off that way instead of being such a jerk, you might not have gotten stuck here bartering for attention. Even if your piece had been passed over anyway, a simple request in the shout box for a review would have been more readily met. But you're being a punk instead. So that's that.

Well I've been contacted directly by several people regardless

I'll have a listen if you post the url and name of the piece. I don't care if you have a score or not. It's immaterial to me.

The midi recording is posted on the website, in the music section of my profile.

http://www.youngcomposers.com/music/listen/6257/

That's nice, but it's not really the behavioral trend of the website. So, nahhh.

You mean people aren't reviewing anymore? Or that I'm a jerk?

*** The midi recording is posted on the website, in the music section of my profile. ***

Fine. What's the name of the piece. I'm beginning to think you're a troll too.

*** The midi recording is posted on the website, in the music section of my profile. ***

 

Fine. What's the name of the piece. I'm beginning to think you're a troll too.

The piece is called Distillation, it's the only piece I have posted.

Oh... I messed up. I didn't even realize you had posted the piece on the site.

Sorry about that. From your wording, I thought you were implying that you had the piece tucked away and would only share it with people who would trade. Sorry! I'll review it today. :)

I have actually listened to it and left a comment.

Don't feel obliged to reciprocate.