selcukozer001 Posted February 13, 2017 Posted February 13, 2017 Hello, Please listen to my piano song. Tell me if you like it. Also check my youtube channel MP3 Play / pause JavaScript is required. 0:00 0:00 volume > next menu dont leave my small dreamland > next Quote
Monarcheon Posted February 16, 2017 Posted February 16, 2017 Right off the bat, you clash a D# with E. I get what you're doing, but maybe make it a little less obvious. 0:37, important that the suspension of the piano happens relatively quickly, since the envelope of the piano sound is so percussive. At the transition to 16th's, the sparse texture of the right hand to the left is a bit strange... supplement it with 8th's maybe. Up to you. 1:20, clashing E with E#. Same around 2:40 and 3:49 and 5:00 Around 4:25, the B in the soprano with A#'s as a neighboring tone is a bit harsh, especially with the B also in the bass. I want a climax! Rising/falling actions. It's a lot of repeating, with not many chord progression changes. Like, it's definitely pretty, but so retrained. I know this can go more places. :) test it out, maybe. Cheers! 1 Quote
selcukozer001 Posted February 16, 2017 Author Posted February 16, 2017 12 hours ago, Monarcheon said: Right off the bat, you clash a D# with E. I get what you're doing, but maybe make it a little less obvious. 0:37, important that the suspension of the piano happens relatively quickly, since the envelope of the piano sound is so percussive. At the transition to 16th's, the sparse texture of the right hand to the left is a bit strange... supplement it with 8th's maybe. Up to you. 1:20, clashing E with E#. Same around 2:40 and 3:49 and 5:00 Around 4:25, the B in the soprano with A#'s as a neighboring tone is a bit harsh, especially with the B also in the bass. I want a climax! Rising/falling actions. It's a lot of repeating, with not many chord progression changes. Like, it's definitely pretty, but so retrained. I know this can go more places. :) test it out, maybe. Cheers! Many thanks for your extensive feedback. Such comments help the beginners a lot. I'll keep your suggestions in my mind and try to revise the song accordingly. Please critisize my future compositions as well. Thank you for taking your time. With regards. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.