Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Guest Bitterduck's Revenge
Posted

Oddly enough. I've seen three women play the 24th caprice on the guitar and only one male. Males tend to perform the 5th. Just something i'm observed.

You should check out Sharon Isbin. She is problem the best or one of the best women classical guitarist out there(after Bob).

Posted

Didn't Jie li play that exact same arrangment of that?

these women are just crazy, I still prefer Andres Segovia over everybody, the problem with these women to me is that they just seem to play, there's no emotion I can detect. IMO it just makes for a dull preformance when all you do is play and you don't put your soul into it. That was really the impression I got from that video, just blinding speed and no emotion.

Guest Bitterduck's Revenge
Posted

With all due respect, The caprices are not really that emotional of a piece.

Posted

Hello young composers,

Bitterduck's Revenge-Sharon Isbin Cool thanks I will look into her when I get the chance.

Nice observation Bitterduck's Revenge why do you think this is?

Carulli_Guitar-I can understand the emotion you want from music.Mabe there was no emotion though I cannot comment.

1- I do not know the music that well and

2- I have not heard it performed by different people.

It was played fast,to me this piece sounded great.I will have to check out Andres Segovia thanks Carulli_Guitar.

Daniel Alley- Haha In answer I have not heard any women or men play paganini works

Paganini is more or less unknown to me apart from the name I know not of his works

Though I really liked this piece I am tempted to get some paganini.

And I have not heard many women play music thanks Daniel Alley.

Where is a good place to begin with paganini if I was to get one of his works?.

Posted

Psshhhttt.... everybody knows that women can't play music... just ask that Giselle guy.... :D

Seriously though.... anybody know the name of the guy who, while discussing big-headed composers, gurgled that famously sexist quote, "There is no feminine version of the word Creator"?

Posted

With all due respect, The caprices are not really that emotional of a piece.

yes, your quite right. But it is possible to put some emotion in there even if it is just a little. All su meng did in the video was play, it's sort of like this

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w1rslEpyfqM

But what I'm talking about is more like this

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mo0nJ7zJF1M

although it is a fast piece and there is not room for alot of emtion. I still find the contrast between these two videos interesting.

I realize they are playing different instruments, but emotion should be universal, it is possible on all instruments (except maybe the drums, but that's different)

Guest Bitterduck's Revenge
Posted

It isn't possible though. A lot of piano pieces lack their true beauty on the guitar. It is lost in translation.

Posted

I realize they are playing different instruments, but emotion should be universal, it is possible on all instruments (except maybe the drums, but that's different)

Excuse me.... but did you just say that emotional playing is impossible on the drums?

Clearly you must be talking about people who can't actually "play" the drums when you say they can't be played with emotion.

Guest Anders
Posted
women who play music

Huh? Never heard of anything like that before. What is it? :blink:

;)

Posted

It isn't possible though. A lot of piano pieces lack their true beauty on the guitar. It is lost in translation.

yes, sadly that is true. what I'm talking about Bitter, is that they could at least TRY to put some emotion in it

And Tumababa, I didn't say it was impossible, I just have never really seen a Timpani or a Snare drummer actually put his soul into his playing. So it is possible, I just haven't seen it done.

Guest Bitterduck's Revenge
Posted

yes, sadly that is true. what I'm talking about Bitter, is that they could at least TRY to put some emotion in it

And Tumababa, I didn't say it was impossible, I just have never really seen a Timpani or a Snare drummer actually put his soul into his playing. So it is possible, I just haven't seen it done.

I believe they are trying but the music isn't very expressiving on the guitar.
Posted

This woman is called su meng she plays caprice No 24 Paganini beautifully.

I do not know much about paganini and I have not heard many women play music though she stopped me listen if you can.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ChZ_YRVk4Mc...ted&search=

she is not a women, she is a man with the body of a woman ...which is very different

good technique...I liked her crecendos. I don't like staccato playing period...I would love to marry a girl as talented as her...

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...