Emanuel Posted May 16, 2019 Posted May 16, 2019 hello guys ! this is my new song!! i hope you like it! any criticism is welcome! Quote
AngelCityOutlaw Posted May 18, 2019 Posted May 18, 2019 I would say that the ostinato on the piano isn't very compelling. It feels kinda random and I'd change the pedal tone to suit the chords better. The drums also feel out of place; I'd expect more toms, taikos, etc. than a drum kit, which is especially jarring because there is no bassline. Another big problem is that the piece does not have a consistent build like most "Epic" pieces. If it's an epic piece that doesn't have that trailer-style build, then it needs to be much clearer in song-structure and the chorus needs to be significantly bigger than everything else. I'd say this piece is a great example of that. Your piece however, doesn't really have this big theme to build up to. In fact, the piece doesn't really have much melody at all. The biggest issue, production-wise, is that the sequencing of the instruments is noticeably fake. The guitar and strings, specifically; the former is especially egregious because electric guitars are extremely-tough to sequence, it isn't double tracked like metal guitars almost always are (thus lacking that wide, stereo sound), and it has way too much gain and mid-scoop and therefore sounds like a swarm of angry bees. I hope some of this helps Quote
Emanuel Posted May 19, 2019 Author Posted May 19, 2019 On 5/18/2019 at 7:41 PM, AngelCityOutlaw said: I would say that the ostinato on the piano isn't very compelling. It feels kinda random and I'd change the pedal tone to suit the chords better. The drums also feel out of place; I'd expect more toms, taikos, etc. than a drum kit, which is especially jarring because there is no bassline. Another big problem is that the piece does not have a consistent build like most "Epic" pieces. If it's an epic piece that doesn't have that trailer-style build, then it needs to be much clearer in song-structure and the chorus needs to be significantly bigger than everything else. I'd say this piece is a great example of that. Your piece however, doesn't really have this big theme to build up to. In fact, the piece doesn't really have much melody at all. The biggest issue, production-wise, is that the sequencing of the instruments is noticeably fake. The guitar and strings, specifically; the former is especially egregious because electric guitars are extremely-tough to sequence, it isn't double tracked like metal guitars almost always are (thus lacking that wide, stereo sound), and it has way too much gain and mid-scoop and therefore sounds like a swarm of angry bees. I hope some of this helps Hello!! thanks for listening and criticism! uff yes i know two steps!! they are professionals,, i a simple novice.. but im going to improve. Thanks! Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.