rbarata Posted January 2, 2020 Posted January 2, 2020 Hello, my friends I'm trying to learn Palestrina by myself and I wrote the song bellow on which I try to follow his "rules" in a general way. I'm sure there are some issues with the piece but I would like you to ear it and comment on what you find, preferencially point to specific points in the piece. Thank you MP3 Play / pause JavaScript is required. 0:00 0:00 volume > next menu My_Palestrina_free_counterpointer V > next Quote
Monarcheon Posted January 2, 2020 Posted January 2, 2020 Firstly, you have wrong intervals in m. 5. You have a lot of note-to-note voice exchanges, i.e. D/B to B/D in mm. 1-2, A/F to F/A in m. 3. These aren't bad, but their overuse makes them sound... well, overused. Parallel 10ths in mm. 9-10 are also not wrong, but don't work so much in his choral style. which is much more based off imitation. Quote
rbarata Posted January 2, 2020 Author Posted January 2, 2020 Thanks for the reply, Monarcheon. Useful tips in your answered. Quote Firstly, you have wrong intervals in m. 5 I've noticed it too late. It should be a 5th and 3rd. Quote You have a lot of note-to-note voice exchanges, i.e. D/B to B/D in mm. 1-2, A/F to F/A in m. 3. I've noticed that in my writing by the time I was composing it, even in other pieces of mine. Something to take into account in future works. Quote Parallel 10ths in mm. 9-10 are also not wrong, but don't work so much in his choral style I've noticed it as I was writing. Consecutive 3rds limited to 3. Considering this, I left them unchanged but that's something I try to avoid. Thanks again.:) Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.